Is the origin of cultivated kumquat species implicated with Hong Kong kumquat? Probably no.

Kumquat (Fortunella spp.), a common fruit crop and ornamental tree, is characterized by small, flavorful, and brilliant orange-like fruit. The cultivated Fortunella species (F. margarita, F. crassifolia, and F. japonica) is known to be originated from China, and is introduced to Europe for the first time by English botanist Robert Fortune during Daoguang period of Qing Dynasty of China. The wild Hong Kong kumquat (F. hindsii) is widely distributed in southern China, and it has been developed as a model material for citrus gene function research due to its dwarfness, short juvenility, and monoembryony characteristics. However, a question on this adorable fruit species has perplexed western (Walter T. Swingle, 1871–1952) and eastern (Tyôzaburô Tanaka, 1885–1976) scholars for the past century: What is the phylogenetic relationship between cultivated Fortunella species and the only existing wild species in this genus F. hindsii? Is the cultivated Fortunella species directly domesticated from F. hindsii or is its origin implicated with F. hindsii?

To answer these questions, Prof. Xiuxin Deng and his team systematically collected the representative cultivated Fortunella accessions and wild F. hindsii samples all over China in the past 10 years. By using nuclear SSR, chloroplast SNP, and genomic SNP, the genetic diversity of Fortunella genus was comprehensively evaluated, and the evolution history of Fortunella genus was traced. The genetic analysis clearly showed the independent phylogeny of Fortunella genus among citrus taxa, which rejected the hybridization origin hypothesis of Fortunella. In addition, Fortunella genus exhibited an obvious genetic structure and high genetic differentiation into the two major populations cultivated Fortunella population and wild F. hindsii population. Genomic analysis showed that both the populations underwent directional selection during their evolutionary trajectory. The asynchronous population dynamics of Fortunella population and wild F. hindsii population during Quaternary glacial period (QGP) was earlier than the human activity in southern China, and the limited domestication signals of these two populations were weakly associated with their phenotype difference together, implying that the cultivated Fortunella species may not be directly domesticated from wild F. hindsii.

Based on the results in this study and previous phylogeographic report, Deng and his team raised a novel evolutionary hypothesis for Fortunella genus. After differentiation from the Citrus genus, the ancestor of Fortunella evolved into an independent lineage which was widely distributed in central and southern China. Along with the progression of QGP, the northern (the ancestor of cultivated Fortunella) and southern populations (the ancestor of F. hindsii) were gradually genetically isolated from each other. The northern population was confronted with earlier and more severe natural selection, thus experiencing an earlier population decline, eventually resulting in adaptive evolution such as thickened peel with the enrichment of sugar and secondary metabolites to protect the seeds from freezing. The southern population encountered moderate and later natural selection, and thus maintaining the primitive phenotype. Along with the southward migration of humans, a few individuals of the northern population were occasionally selected and then cultivated, and thus they survived till now, known as Nagami (F. margarita), Meiwa (F. crassifolia), and Marumi (F. japonica). The southern population mainly underwent continuous natural selection and was discovered successively by ancient Chinese horticulturalists and modern western scholars, and they were named as “Shan Jin’gan” in Chinese and “Hong Kong kumquat” in English, respectively.

This study is innovative and illuminating, providing useful information for both breeding and conservation of Fortunella. The evolutionary hypothesis also provides a new perspective for profound research on the phylogeny of this genus, which still calls for more solid evidences such as related fossil evidence, and more advanced method such as pan-genome analysis. This study has been published on the Journal of Frontiers of Agricultural Science and Engineering in 2022.

Original article

Chenqiao ZHU, Peng CHEN, Junli YE, Hang LI, Yue HUANG, Xiaoming YANG, Chuanwu CHEN, Chenglei ZHANG, Yuantao XU, Xiaoli WANG, Xiang YAN, Guangzhou DENG, Xiaolin JIANG, Nan WANG, Hongxing WANG, Quan SUN, Yun LIU, Di FENG, Min YU, Xietian SONG, Zongzhou XIE, Yunliu ZENG, Lijun CHAI, Qiang XU, Chongling DENG, Yunjiang CHENG, Xiuxin DENG. NEW INSIGHTS INTO THE PHYLOGENY AND SPECIATION OF KUMQUAT (FORTUNELLA SPP.) BASED ON CHLOROPLAST SNP, NUCLEAR SSR AND WHOLE-GENOME SEQUENCING. Frontiers of Agricultural Science and Engineering, 2022 [Published Online] DOI: 10.15302/J-FASE-2021436

About Higher Education Press

Founded in May 1954, Higher Education Press Limited Company (HEP), affiliated with the Ministry of Education, is one of the earliest institutions committed to educational publishing after the establishment of P. R. China in 1949. After striving for six decades, HEP has developed into a major comprehensive publisher, with products in various forms and at different levels. Both for import and export, HEP has been striving to fill in the gap of domestic and foreign markets and meet the demand of global customers by collaborating with more than 200 partners throughout the world and selling products and services in 32 languages globally. Now, HEP ranks among China's top publishers in terms of copyright export volume and the world's top 50 largest publishing enterprises in terms of comprehensive strength.

The Frontiers Journals series published by HEP includes 28 English academic journals, covering the largest academic fields in China at present. Among the series, 13 have been indexed by SCI, 6 by EI, 2 by MEDLINE, 1 by A&HCI. HEP's academic monographs have won about 300 different kinds of publishing funds and awards both at home and abroad.

About Frontiers of Agricultural Science and Engineering

Frontiers of Agricultural Science and Engineering (FASE) is an international journal, which is aimed to publish papers that advance the understanding of scientific, technological/engineering, socioeconomic, institutional/policy and management factors that drive current and future agricultural productivity and sustainability. Our goal is to use FASE as a platform to foster scientific information flow, stimulate transdisciplinary inquiries that have strong multi-disciplinary connections, and cultivate research and idea exchanges that address agricultural sustainability challenges regionally and globally. 

FASE is an open-access journal published quarterly with no page charges. Contributions may include cutting-edge research, science news, commentaries, perspectives, or reviews. In addition to publishing regular review and research articles, the journal also publishes ‘Hot Topic’ issues that focus on strategically selected subject matter of high impact, or emerging concerns to address future agricultural development pathways at regional and global levels, and are guest-edited by scientists in their areas of research. Proposals for special issues are welcome and can be submitted any time.