image: LOASIS has produced well-formed electron beams with energies up to a billion electron volts in laser plasma accelerators just 3.3 centimeters long. A typical laser set-up is shown above, with the billion-electron-volt accelerating module in the inset. Below, a laser wakefield accelerates a pulse of electrons (bright yellow and green) in this computer simulation. view more
Credit: Photos Roy Kaltschmidt, simulation Cameron Geddes, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Focusing in on beam focus
The rapidly evolving technology of laser plasma accelerators (LPAs) – called "table-top accelerators" because their length can be measured in centimeters instead of kilometers – promises a new breed of machines, far less expensive and with far less impact on the land and the environment than today's conventional accelerators.
Future LPAs offer not only compact high-energy colliders for fundamental physics but diminutive light sources as well. These will probe chemical reactions, from artificial photosynthesis to "green catalysis"; unique biological structures, inaccessible to other forms of microscopy yet essential to understanding life and health; and new materials, including low-temperature superconductors, topological insulators, spintronics devices, and graphene nanostructures, which will revolutionize the electronics industry. With intensely bright beams spanning the spectrum from microwaves to gamma rays, table-top accelerators open new vistas of science.
LOASIS, the Laser and Optical Accelerator Systems Integrated Studies program at the U.S. Department of Energy's Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (Berkeley Lab), demonstrated the first LPA beams with a narrow spread of energies in 2004, and by 2006 was first to reach energies of a billion electron volts. But because of their unique method of acceleration and their pulses only femtoseconds long (mere quadrillionths of a second), testing the quality of LPA beams isn't easy.
Wim Leemans of Berkeley Lab's Accelerator and Fusion Research Division (AFRD) heads LOASIS, which has continued to extend and improve LPA performance with teams uniting theorists, experts in computer simulation, and gifted experimentalists – teams in which students earning their Ph.D's are often important contributors to the work. Leemans assigned Guillaume Plateau, a graduate of the École Polytechnique near Paris (and now a postdoc at the University of California at Los Angeles) to investigate radiation associated with LPA x ray production as part of his dissertation.
"We had a grant to study laser plasma accelerators as x ray and gamma-ray light sources, and we wanted to know more about background radiation," Leemans says. "In a serendipitous development, we found more than we had expected."
The LPA measurement challenge
The conventional way of accelerating charged particles like electrons is with an oscillating electromagnetic field, controlled by metal vacuum cavities that make up the segments of the accelerator. The oscillations are timed so the field pulls the electrons forward as they enter each cavity; the field strength is the "accelerating gradient," expressed as volts (typically millions of volts) per meter. Conventional accelerators may require many segments and stretch for miles.
A laser plasma accelerator works very differently. When a powerful laser focuses a pulse on a plasma of free electrons and positive ions, its radiation pressure pushes the electrons and ions apart, creating strong accelerating gradients. Some of the electrons "surf" the resulting wave behind the pulse, in a bunch that almost instantaneously reaches near light-speed. Over short distances, LPAs have sustained accelerating gradients of hundreds of billions of volts per meter, immensely stronger than those of conventional accelerators.
An LPA's intense laser pulses and short electron bunches require new measurement techniques to understand performance. One particularly challenging gauge of performance is emittance.
"This parameter determines how well the beams can be focused," says Cameron Geddes of LOASIS, who worked with Plateau on the experiment. "Low emittance means the velocity of the particles isn't random – they travel nearly along streamlines."
When the experiment began, however, emittance wasn't at the center of attention. Says Leemans, "Since we wanted to get images of the x-ray pulses associated with the electron beam, we formed a collaboration with colleagues at GSI" – Germany's Center for Heavy Ion Research – "who came to Berkeley with an excellent commercial camera. We were impressed by what we could see, so we asked ourselves what more we could do with these images."
Marco Battaglia of the Lab's Engineering Division then supplied a more advanced camera, using rugged, sensitive Berkeley Lab CCDs, which yielded even better information. Says Leemans, "We were not the first to image LPA x rays, but because of the quality of the new cameras, we were able to measure the x-ray spectrum in detail. From that we worked backward to see what we could learn about the electron bunch."
Geddes explains that emittance can be measured as the product of the beam size and its angle of spread (divergence). Traditional methods for measuring emittance use devices like "pepper-pots" or wire scanners, placed right in the accelerator beam – which can destroy a low-emittance beam. And with an LPA, the powerful drive laser can destroy the diagnostic devices themselves.
The LOASIS team could measure the energy and dispersion of the LPA electron bunch by deflecting it with magnets, then dumping it. But to determine emittance, they had to measure the size of the beam before it left the accelerator. X-ray spectroscopy gave them the means.
"With x-ray imaging we had a way to measure beam quality right inside the plasma, where the laser wakefield is accelerating the electron bunch," says Geddes. That's because the x-rays are a manifestation of what's called betatron radiation, generated by electrons inside the accelerating "bubble" that trails immediately behind the laser pulse. As the electrons gather in the bubble they swing back and forth. This betatron oscillation emits a forward-directed throb of x-rays – tight, bright, and ultrashort.
The laser beam, the electron beam, and the x-rays all travel in the same direction. To measure the x-rays without interference, the experimenters first dumped the electron beam and then deflected the laser beam with a mirrored foil. The x-ray pulse passed through the foil to the CCD camera, which was capable of counting every x-ray photon and measuring its energy. Although the camera was almost five meters from the accelerator, the spectrum of the tight betatron pulse it captured carried the information necessary to determine the beam radius.
"By comparing their x-ray spectra to theoretical predictions, we pegged the electron beams in these experiments at a radius of 0.1 micrometer, a tenth of a millionth of meter," Geddes says. "This is smaller than any previous experiment could resolve, allowing us to estimate the emittance across the beam – in terms of how far the momentum of the particles spreads within an angular slice of the beam – to be as low as 0.1 millimeter per thousandth of a radian."
Geddes adds, "This transverse emittance is as good as state-of-the-art conventional accelerators for free electron lasers and gamma-ray sources, if not yet high enough for a high-energy collider. Our numerical simulations show us that emittance depends on specific ways in which the electrons are trapped in the wave, which opens the door to further reducing emittance."
There are other measures of LPA beam quality that also depend on special radiation but leave their mark outside the accelerator. A separate report, coming soon, will investigate the phenomenon of slice-energy spread in an electron beam.
"Low-emittance electron bunches from a laser-plasma accelerator measured using single-shot x-ray spectroscopy," by G. R. Plateau, C. G. R. Geddes, D. B. Thorn, M. Chen, C. Benedetti, E. Esarey, A. J. Gonsalves, N. H. Matlis, K. Nakamura, C. B. Schroeder, S. Shiraishi, T. Sokollik, J. van Tilborg, Cs. Toth, S. Trotsenko, T. S. Kim, M. Battaglia, Th. Stöhlker, and W. P. Leemans, appears in Physical Review Letters and is available online at http://prl.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v109/i6/e064802.
Earlier research on LPA beam quality is described at http://newscenter.lbl.gov/news-releases/2011/08/22/beams-to-order/
For the role of simulation in designing LPAs, see http://newscenter.lbl.gov/news-releases/2011/03/17/simulating-at-lightspeed/
More about 2006's world-record 1-GeV LPA is at http://www.lbl.gov/Science-Articles/Archive/AFRD-GeV-beams.html
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory addresses the world's most urgent scientific challenges by advancing sustainable energy, protecting human health, creating new materials, and revealing the origin and fate of the universe. Founded in 1931, Berkeley Lab's scientific expertise has been recognized with 13 Nobel prizes. The University of California manages Berkeley Lab for the U.S. Department of Energy's Office of Science. For more, visit www.lbl.gov.
DOE's Office of Science is the single largest supporter of basic research in the physical sciences in the United States, and is working to address some of the most pressing challenges of our time. For more information, please visit the Office of Science website at science.energy.gov/.