News Release

Electronic markets win out over traditional dealing

Peer-Reviewed Publication

Economic & Social Research Council

Trading through dealers on the London Stock Exchange could be obsolete in less than three years, according to new research funded by the Economic and Social Research Council.

A study led by Dr Nir Vulkan of the Saïd Business School and Worcester College, University of Oxford, investigated where traders would trade if they have the choice of either a dealers' market or a computerised system. "Our study suggests that in a just a few years' time the traditional dealing market on the London Stock Exchange will become obsolete unless steps are taken to make it more attractive," states Dr Vulkan.

This finding results from a study designed to understand why buyers and sellers participate in electronic markets for trading goods and services, and the consequences of these decisions for the efficiency of electronic markets. "Our research was motivated by advances in information technology (e.g. Electronic Data Interchanges, B2B exchanges and Electronic Communication Networks) which mean buyers and sellers now have a real choice of where to trade for raw materials, office supplies and related services and for buying and selling stocks, bonds and future contracts, " he explains.

Researchers looked at data collected from the London Stock Exchange (LSE). In October 1997, the LSE introduced an automated Stock Exchange Electronic Trading Service (SETS), to complement the existing quote-driven dealership market, (Stock Exchange Automated Quotation system or SEAQ) where trade is based around direct negotiation between the trader and market maker. SETS is an order-driven trading mechanism, established to lower trading costs and increase trade volumes.

Exploration of this data from the LSE confirms the research team's earlier theoretical hypothesis: that 'weak' traders (e.g. sellers selling only a small number of shares) are attracted to the anonymous electronic marketplace, and furthermore, once 'weak' traders have moved to the electronic market, then the remaining 'weakest' traders (who where not particularly 'weak' before) will now be disadvantaged from trading in the dealer's market and will switch to trading in the electronic marketplace. The theory concludes that in the absence of additional incentives this process will continue until, finally, all traders have moved to the electronic market.

Ultimately, he believes, this unravelling process will lead to the growth of the automated SETS mechanism at the expense of traditional dealer markets. Moreover, this finding is likely to hold true not only for other financial markets (including bonds) but commodity markets such as steel. "This process is already at work in the bond market where the computerised market for trading bonds is growing rapidly," he suggests. Moreover, on the consumer side, a recent study of transaction prices for new cars purchased online and offline concludes that the Internet is disproportionately beneficial to those who have personal characteristics that put them at a disadvantage in negotiations i.e. those who correspond to the 'weak' traders type.

"The one barrier to the unravelling process predicted by the theory is any step that would make the dealer market more attractive," suggests Dr Vulkan. "For example, low commissions offered in the dealers market will increase the attractiveness of this form of trading. And evidence suggests that the flexibility of these commissions will ensure that large trade continues to take place in SEAQ because large traders are able to negotiate soft commissions," he concludes.

###

For further information:

Contact Dr Nir Vulkan, The Saïd Business School, Park End Street, Oxford OX1 1HP, e-mail: nir.vulkan@sbs.ox.ac.uk TEL: 01865 288800

Or Lesley Lilley or Anna Hinds at ESRC, on 44-179-341-3119/413122

NOTES FOR EDITORS

1. The research report 'Understanding Electronic Markets' was funded by the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC). Dr Nir Vulkan is a University Lecturer in the Saïd Business School, and a Fellow of Worcester College, University of Oxford.
2. The ESRC is the UK's largest funding agency for research and postgraduate training relating to social and economic issues. It provides independent, high-quality, relevant research to business, the public sector and Government. The ESRC invests more than £76 million every year in social science and at any time is supporting some 2,000 researchers in academic institutions and research policy institutes. It also funds postgraduate training within the social sciences to nurture the researchers of tomorrow. More at http://www.esrc.ac.uk
3. REGARD is the ESRC's database of research. It provides a key source of information on ESRC social science research awards and all associated publications and products. The website can be found at http://www.regard.ac.uk.


Disclaimer: AAAS and EurekAlert! are not responsible for the accuracy of news releases posted to EurekAlert! by contributing institutions or for the use of any information through the EurekAlert system.