This paper provides an extensive analysis of the proportion of the risk of upper aero-digestive tract (UADT) cancers in the population (the population attributable risk) that may be due to alcohol consumption and/or smoking. The analyse provides strong evidence that smoking is the most important factor in the risk of these cancers, and the risk is enhanced among those who smoke and also consume 2 or more drinks per day. Alcohol alone (i.e., among non-smokers) has little effect on the risk (less than 1%).
The authors state that their observations "are consistent with the hypothesis that alcohol acts as a carcinogen primarily because of its promoting effect on tobacco smoke." In terms of the population-attributable risk, the authors conclude that "Our findings confirm that tobacco and alcohol together explain 73% of total UADT cancer burden in Europe." Overall, tobacco use alone explained 28.7%, the combination of smoking and drinking 43.9%, and alcohol use alone only 0.4% of the population attributable risk. However, among women, the risk of these cancers was higher among smokers than among those who both smoked and consumed alcohol.
Comments on the present paper: This was a case-control analysis, which is usual for uncommon types of cancer. Controls were matched on age, gender, and area of residence, but some of the analyses also adjusted for educational level. Forum members thought it unusual that the investigators considered as "ever drinkers" only subjects reporting 2 or more drinks per day; in most countries, the majority of light-to-moderate drinkers would be classified as never drinkers by this definition. The data presented do not permit an evaluation of effects for lower levels of alcohol intake. However, given that even at 2 or more drinks per day the effects of alcohol alone on population attributable risk were very small, it could be assumed that lighter drinking may have even less of a direct effect on the risk of these cancers.
No information was available on diet (e.g., fruit and vegetable intake) or other lifestyle habits that may affect cancer risk. Thus, it is not possible to judge whether subjects who were both smokers and drinkers may have had other unhealthy lifestyle habits as well. Smoking and drinking might be just two visible markers of subjects with many unhealthy lifestyle habits.
Forum reviewers thought that this was a very good paper, but hoped that in the future we would have more studies that evaluated the effects on risk of varying levels of alcohol consumption, differential effects of various beverages, and even differential effects according to subjects' genetically determined differences in alcohol metabolizing enzymes.
Reference: Anantharaman D, Marron M, Lagiou P, Samoli E, Ahrens W, Pohlabeln H, et al. Population attributable risk of tobacco and alcohol for upper aerodigestive tract cancer. Oral Oncology 2011;47:725-731.
Comments on this paper were provided by the following members of the International Scientific Forum on Alcohol Research:
Erik Skovenborg, MD, Scandinavian Medical Alcohol Board, Practitioner, Aarhus, Denmark
Harvey Finkel, MD, Hematology/Oncology, Boston University Medical Center, Boston, MA, USA
Giovanni de Gaetano, MD, PhD, Research Laboratories, Catholic University, Campobasso, Italy
R. Curtis Ellison, MD, Section of Preventive Medicine & Epidemiology, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA
Arne Svilaas, MD, PhD, general practice and lipidology, Oslo University Hospital, Oslo, Norway
For the detailed critique of this paper by the International Scientific Forum on Alcohol Research, go to www.bu.edu/alcohol-forum and click on Recent Reports.
The specialists who are members of the Forum are happy to respond to questions from Health Editors regarding emerging research on alcohol and health and will offer an independent opinion in context with other research on the subject
International Scientific Forum on Alcohol Research
Examining risks and benefits of alcohol consumption
www.bu.edu/alcohol-forum
www.alcoholforum4profs.org
Critique 054. Role of alcohol intake and smoking on upper aerodigestive cancers 6 September 2011
Read the full critique here: http://www.bu.edu/alcohol-forum/critique-054-role-of-alcohol-intake-and-smoking-on-upper-aerodigestive-cancers-6-september-2011/
Contacts for Editors
Professor R Curtis Ellison: ellison@bu.edu
Tel: +1 508 333-1256
Helena Conibear: helena@alcohol-forum4profs.org
Tel: +44 1300 320869 or +44 7876 593 345